Tree Removal vs Tree Surgery: What’s the Best Option for Your Garden?
Trees are a beautiful and valuable part of your landscape — but when they become overgrown, diseased, or dangerous, it can be hard to know what to do next. Should you remove the tree completely or try to save it with expert tree surgery?
At Gus Bishop Tree Services, we help homeowners across North Yorkshire and beyond make the right choice. In this post, we break down the differences between tree removal and tree surgery, so you can choose the best option for your garden — and your budget.
What’s the Difference Between Tree Removal and Tree Surgery?
Understanding these two common services is essential when it comes to tree care in the UK.
What is Tree Removal?
Tree removal (also known as tree felling) involves cutting down a tree completely — typically when it's:
Dead or dying
Damaging property or underground pipes
Structurally unstable
Unsafe after storm damage
What is Tree Surgery?
Tree surgery includes a range of services that improve a tree's health and structure without removing it. This may involve:
Crown reduction
Branch removal
Tree pruning
Deadwood removal
When Should You Choose Tree Removal?
Removing a tree is usually the last resort, but sometimes it’s the only safe or practical option. Choose removal if:
The tree is completely dead or diseased beyond recovery
It poses a risk to people, pets or property
It's growing too close to buildings, driveways, or power lines
You need to clear space for landscaping or construction
Warning Signs a Tree Should Be Removed
Large cracks in the trunk
Severe leaning
Fungus growing at the base
Hollow or brittle branches
Root lifting or pavement damage
When is Tree Surgery the Better Option?
Tree surgery is the preferred solution if the tree is:
Healthy, but overgrown
Blocking sunlight
Near power lines but otherwise structurally sound
A protected species that can't be removed (TPOs apply)
Regular surgery can extend a tree’s lifespan, improve aesthetics, and reduce future costs by avoiding major damage.
What’s More Cost-Effective — Tree Surgery or Tree Removal?
Tree Surgery Cost in the UK
Tree surgery is typically more affordable than full removal
Prices range from £150 to £500, depending on the size and scope
Ideal for routine maintenance and long-term value
Tree Removal Cost in the UK
Full tree removal ranges from £400 to £1,200+, depending on:
Tree size
Location access
Waste removal and stump grinding
Can You Do It Yourself? Why Hire a Professional Tree Surgeon
Tree work is not DIY-friendly — it’s dangerous, technical, and often regulated. Hiring a professional ensures:
Full insurance coverage
Legal compliance (especially with Tree Preservation Orders)
Clean, tidy removal with no mess left behind
Proper waste disposal or wood recycling
Not Sure Which Service You Need? Let’s Talk.
Whether your tree needs a trim or it’s time to say goodbye, we’ll guide you to the best, safest option.
📞 Call us on 07738429588
📧 Or request a free quote: info@gusbishoptreeservices.co.uk